When Space Debris Hit Your House, Who Do You Sue?
On the March 8th 2024, Daniel Otero, then nineteen, was home alone in Naples, Florida, when something punched through the roof and tore through two floors, missing him by a few feet. It was a lump of metal from the International Space Station. Specifically, a battery mount that NASA had thrown overboard in 2021 and assumed would burn up on re-entry into the Earth’s atmosphere, and thus not fall to Earth after that. That is not what happened.
Nine months later, on the December 30th, a half-tonne metal ring fell, still red-hot, into Mukuku, a village in southern Kenya. “I was looking after my cow and I heard a loud bang,” resident Joseph Mutua told a local broadcaster.
Two families, two continents, one problem. When something falls out of orbit and lands on you, it is surprisingly hard to get justice. Space law was built for States, not for the people standing underneath it.
A regime built for governments
The rules come from the 1967 Outer Space Treaty and the 1972 Liability Convention. On paper they are strong: a launching State is “absolutely liable” for damage its space objects cause on the ground. But the Convention only lets States bring claims against other States. The injured person has no standing. Their government must take up the case for them, through diplomatic channels, and it is under no obligation to do so.
In more than fifty years, that machinery has been used in earnest exactly once, after a Soviet nuclear satellite scattered debris across Canada in 1978. Even then the two governments settled quietly, and the Convention’s claims commission never sat. It still hasn’t.
A lottery of geography
The Otero family showed how arbitrary this is. Because NASA’s debris was American and fell on American soil, the Convention did not apply at all. The family had to claim against their own government for negligence under ordinary US law, seeking $80,000. Their lawyer claimed that had the same wreckage struck someone overseas, Washington would have been absolutely liable to pay under the Convention, yet a victim at home had to prove fault.
In Kenya the problem is worse. The launching State is unknown. The Kenya Space Agency says it will use “existing legal mechanisms under international law” once it identifies the owner. However, until a State is named, there is no one to claim against, and no court an individual can walk into.
The person under the debris
Access to justice means that the person harmed has a real route to a remedy, for a human rights NGO, this is the heart of it.. Human rights law already promises exactly that. The right to an effective remedy sits in Article 2(3) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Space law routes around it, treating the casualty as something for governments to settle between themselves, if they bother.
And the skies are filling. More hardware re-enters every month, the mega-constellations keep multiplying, and the people most likely to be hit are the communities beneath the are the ones with the fewest ways to seek redress. It doesn’t help that these communities are often in the countries
As more goes up, more will come down. The test of the law we build is whether the teenager in Naples, or the herder in Mukuku, can find a door to a courtroom. Right now, that door is mostly shut. Opening it is exactly what access to justice means.
Support our work!
We can only do our work thanks to the support of brave, passionate people like you!
Your donation will help us to keep fighting for human rights and access to justice for everyone, everywhere.
